Broken Wing Pizzeria and Grille

Located in the heart of Olean, NY, Broken Wing Pizzeria and Grille is a lively bar & grill that brings together delicious comfort food and a welcoming, no-frills atmosphere. This neighborhood staple is perfect for those seeking hearty meals paired with cold drinks, all served up in a space that feels like a genuine community hub.

Broken Wing’s menu showcases a variety of mouthwatering options, with signature sandwiches that are as generous in size as they are in flavor. The Keis Cuban stands out as a savory masterpiece—succulent roasted pork shoulder hand-pulled to perfection, layered alongside thin slices of ham, Swiss cheese, zesty dill pickles, and mustard, all nested within a freshly baked 12-inch roll. Another favorite, the Italian sandwich, offers a delightful melange of ham, salami, pepperoni, and capicola accented by provolone cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato, and garlic mayo, lightly toasted to bring the flavors together. For those who crave classic deli flavors, the Reuben with tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss, and creamy 1,000 island on rye bread is a satisfying choice.

The grill’s salads provide fresh, vibrant alternatives with hearty chops of grilled or crispy chicken, traditional ingredients like olives, feta, and pepperoncini, and crisp greens dressed to perfection. Whether it’s the Greek Salad or the robust Italian Salad, these dishes bring a refreshing balance to the menu and cater beautifully to those looking for lighter fare without sacrificing taste.

Complement your meal with classic sides—hand-cut fries dusted with coarse-grained salt, creamy cole slaw, or a crisp side salad—that all add that extra touch of comfort and homestyle goodness. The cozy, casual setting of Broken Wing invites diners to relax, whether coming for a casual lunch, a lively night out with friends, or to enjoy live entertainment in the ample bar space.

Customers consistently praise the friendly and attentive service, led by Brian and his dedicated crew, who ensure each visit feels personal and enjoyable. Regulars applaud the generous portions and great value, while newcomers can expect the kind of honest, satisfying food that keeps people coming back. One guest raved about the personal pizzas—hand tossed with a crispy crust and topped with just the right balance of sauce and cheese—while others appreciate the cold draft beers on tap and the approachable, laid-back vibe of the space.

Broken Wing Pizzeria and Grille might not be fancy, but therein lies its charm. It’s a clean, welcoming spot where guests can savor hearty burgers, expertly crafted sandwiches, and wings that deliver big bold flavors. This is a place to kick back, enjoy good company, and indulge in genuine bar & grill fare made with care.

If you’re in Olean looking for a spot that blends great food, friendly faces, and a slice of local life, Broken Wing Pizzeria and Grille stands out as a reliable, satisfying choice that feels like home.